Can you put mascara on eyelash extensions?

Eyelash extensions can magnify your eyes and eliminate the need for daily mascara applications.

Yet, beauty adventurers and newcomers to this beauty trend often ask, “Can you put mascara on eyelash extensions?”

The answer deserves a nuanced approach, and here, we will unveil the ins and outs of pairing mascara with eyelash extensions.

Understand the Basics: Water-Based Vs. Oil-Based Mascara

Before reaching for your mascara tube, it’s essential to recognize the distinction between oil-based mascara and water-based mascara.

Oil-based mascaras can weaken the bond of the lash adhesive, leading to premature fallout of your extensions.

Oil-based mascaras contain ingredients that can interfere with the lash adhesive used in eyelash extensions. These ingredients often act as solvents, breaking down the chemical structure of the adhesive, which is designed to be durable yet sensitive. When the oil comes into contact with the adhesive, it leads to a softening effect, reducing the adhesive’s grip on the natural lashes. This weakening of the bond means that eyelash extensions can become loose and fall out much sooner than their expected lifespan. Therefore, choosing the correct type of mascara is crucial to maintaining the longevity and appearance of your eyelash extensions.

On the other hand, water-based mascaras are more forgiving on the lashes and the adhesive used. If you must wear mascara, the good news is you can opt for a water-based product if you need a more voluminous look.

Related: How to Care for your Lash Extensions

The Impact of Mascara on Lash Adhesive

The adhesive that holds your eyelash extensions in place can react poorly to certain mascaras.

Many mascaras contain ingredients that may dissolve lash glue, reducing the longevity of your extensions. Continuous use of inappropriate mascaras could lead to more frequent fills, which equates to more time and expense.

When it comes to waterproof mascara and lash extensions, common wisdom suggests avoidance. Waterproof mascaras typically have a formulation that requires a strong makeup remover, often oil-based, to completely clean off.

This means that while the mascara itself might not directly harm the adhesive, the process of removing it almost certainly will.

The vigorous rubbing and the oil-based removers can break down the lash adhesive, leading to a loss of extensions. Therefore, even though waterproof mascara can withstand tears and humidity, it is not recommended for use with eyelash extensions due to the implications during the removal process.

Opting for a water-based tube mascara remains the safest option for maintaining the integrity of your lash extensions.

Exploring Different Types of Mascaras

A myriad of mascara formulas awaits on the shelves, each boasting attributes like lengthening, volumizing, or curling.

However, not all formulations are suitable for use over extensions. The right product won’t overload your extensions but instead will complement them gently.

Seek out mascaras specifically formulated for use with extensions; many times, these will be water-based and come with a seal of approval from your lash technician.

Fiber mascaras, often touted for their lengthening effects, contain tiny fibers that adhere to your natural lashes, creating the illusion of greater length and volume. While this may seem like an attractive option for those seeking dramatic eyelash enhancement, it’s not recommended for those with lash extensions.

The fibers can become entangled with the extensions, leading to clumping and an unnatural appearance. More critically, the process of removing fiber mascara often necessitates rubbing or pulling at the lashes, which can cause extensions to fall out prematurely or damage the natural lashes. For these reasons, individuals with lash extensions should steer clear of fiber mascaras to maintain the health and longevity of their extensions.

The Naked Truth: Why Mascara May Be Unnecessary

Eyelash extensions impart similar effects as mascara—they add volume, length, and curve to the natural lash line.

Therefore, one might argue that the added layer of mascara is superfluous. If applied correctly, extensions offer the same darkening and thickening effects as a swipe of your beloved lash cosmetic- or much more.

For those accustomed to the dramatic look of mascara and finding lash extensions somewhat lacking in drama, volume lashes present a compelling alternative to classic lashes.

Unlike classic eyelash extensions, which are applied on a one-to-one ratio with natural lashes, volume extensions involve applying a fan of multiple thinner lashes to each natural lash.

This technique not only multiplies the perceived volume of the lash line but also achieves a darker, more pronounced look akin to that of several coats of mascara. Opting for volume lash extensions over classic lash extensions can fulfill the desire for a more dramatic eye appearance without the need for mascara, reducing potential damage and prolonging the life of the extensions.

Mascara on Lower Lashes?

While upper eyelash extensions usually mean saying goodbye to mascara, the story might change when considering your lower lashes.

It’s generally safe to apply a delicate wand of mascara there, as long as you’re cautious to prevent contact with your extensions.

However, even when applying mascara solely to the bottom lashes, it’s important to consider the interconnectedness of the eye area. Mascara applied to the bottom lashes might inadvertently affect the upper lash extensions during routine activities such as blinking, crying, or even cleansing the face.

Particles from the mascara can transfer onto the upper lashes, potentially weakening the bonding agents of the false lashes and contaminating their pristine appearance. This is particularly true for oil-based mascaras, which can dissolve the glue that holds the extensions in place, leading to premature shedding.

Consequently, even when focusing mascara application on the lower lashes, choosing a product that is extension-safe and exercising meticulous care during application and removal is crucial for maintaining the integrity of both the extensions and the natural lashes.

The Role of Makeup Remover

Removing mascara usually involves makeup removers, which, similar to the wrong type of mascara, can affect the adhesive’s integrity. Oil-based makeup remover is a surefire way to loosen your lash extensions.

It’s a good idea to opt for a gentle, oil-free remover to tackle any lower-lash mascara without putting your upper extensions at risk.

Beyond selecting the appropriate makeup remover, it’s equally important to avoid oil-based cleansers that might inadvertently come into contact with your lash extensions. These cleansers can similarly break down the adhesive, just like oil-based makeup removers, leading to a weakened bond and potentially causing the extensions to fall out prematurely.

Opting for a gentle, oil-free facial cleanser ensures that the integrity of the lash extensions is preserved, even during your daily skincare routine. It’s worthwhile to meticulously select products that are safe for use around the eye area to maintain the longevity and appearance of your lash extensions. Your lash artist may even carry some as well.

Micellar water can be a game-changer for those with lash extensions looking for a safe and effective cleanser to protect their new lashes. This unique formulation, which contains micelles, or tiny lipid molecules suspended in water, works like a magnet to attract and lift away dirt, oil, and makeup without the need for harsh rubbing or rinsing.

Unlike traditional cleansers and makeup removers, most micellar waters are free of oils, alcohols, and sulfates, making them an excellent choice for gently cleansing the delicate eye area without compromising the adhesive bond of lash extensions. When using micellar water, it’s advisable to apply it to a cotton pad and gently press over the lashes, avoiding any side-to-side rubbing. This method ensures that the lash extensions remain intact and look their best between refill appointments.

Considering Alternatives: Lash Lift for Mascara Lovers

For those who cannot part with their mascara ritual, a lash lift could be a promising compromise. This procedure gives natural lashes a semi-permanent curl, allowing for the regular use of mascara without the worry of affecting extensions.

For a special occasion, playing up your lash lift can add that extra touch of glamour to your look. To enhance the volume and drama a lash lift, applying a water-based mascara can further amplify the length and curl, giving your natural lashes an extraordinary lift and definition.

Additionally, using an eyelash serum on your lash line can strengthen and nourish your lashes, ensuring they remain healthy and can support the added weight of mascara or more dramatic extensions.

To Mascara, or Not to Mascara?

At the end of the day, while applying mascara over eyelash extensions is doable, it’s often discouraged. The beauty of lash extensions lies in their ability to make your eyes pop without additional makeup and even gives you the opportunity to simplify your makeup routine.

If you do choose to use mascara, remember to pick a water-based product, apply sparingly, and avoid oil-based cleaners when removing it so they don’t weaken the eyelash glue.

Eyelash extension enthusiasts and rookies alike, cherish your beautiful lashes and consider the answers above as your guide when pondering the right mascara. Enjoy the liberating experience of waking up to perfect false eyelashes every day, with or without that extra coat of mascara.